FANGORIA Mystery Bag


MYSTERY: the apex of fear, and the culmination of excitement. Tantalize your lust for the unknown with FANGORIA’s beguiling mystery bags. Inside these amorphous black shapes, you’ll find secret FANGORIA merch and eldritch collectibles. 

These bags make a great gift for horror fans, and a fun care package for college students.

If you are lucky enough you may even find a Volume 1 Issue #1!!!

“The process of delving into the black abyss is to me the keenest form of fascination” - H.P. Lovecraft

“These FANGORIA mystery bags go hard” - also H.P. Lovecraft

Vintage items may vary in condition. All sales are final. Bags are packed completely at random with 3 Vintage past issues - including special editions, poster mags, special coverage issues, Bags may include other items such as pins, posters, toys, comics, trading cards, etc.  These are packed at random within the FANGORIA Vault & Archives. 


**Discounts are not applicable for this item. Limited Quantity.**

Secure & Trusted Checkout with


Since 1979, FANGORIA has lived up to its moniker as “First In Fright,” growing across the decades to become one of the most influential horror brands in the genre. Starting as a print magazine, FANGORIA has grown and evolved into a multimedia platform company, spanning across print, digital, studio (film and television), podcasts, merchandise and more.

How do I renew my subscription?

Subscriptions are automatically renewed on an annual basis, if you aren’t sure if your account is set to auto renew or have questions about your subscription, email

Can I purchase previous back issues?

Yes, you can purchase prior individual issues here (while supplies last). Since they are collectibles, if they sell out, they are gone! You can also check out our archives page to read vintage Volume 1 issues here

“As a lifelong horror fan, I've found no better resource than FANGORIA. Every issue is packed with riveting articles, unique interviews, and high-quality visuals that cater to my morbid curiosity. Highly recommended!”

Steve W.


Taxes and shipping calculated at checkout

Your cart is empty
Continue shopping